Vacation Rental Management
Vacation Rental Management in St. Augustine, FL
From the beach roads of Crescent Beach and Butler Beach to the streets of the old city, Fairly runs St. Augustine vacation rentals: pricing, guest messaging, listings on Airbnb, Vrbo and Fairly.com, a vetted local caretaker for every turnover, and Florida and St. Johns County lodging taxes collected and remitted on every booking.
4.8
Average review across Fairly homes
Fairly is an Airbnb Superhost, and our homes average 4.84 stars across 21,000+ guest reviews. 87% of those reviews are five stars. Better reviews attract better guests, at higher prices, maximizing your revenue.
What our guests say
St. Augustine market overview
St. Augustine combines a Spanish colonial city with a long run of Atlantic beach. Visitors walk the old streets and the Castillo de San Marcos, the oldest masonry fort in the continental United States, then stay out on Anastasia Island at Crescent Beach, Butler Beach and St. Augustine Beach, or north across the inlet at Vilano Beach.
The year has two peaks. March is the spring high, with three nights in four booked, and February is close behind. December is the other: the Nights of Lights display runs from late November into January, and December carries the year's highest nightly rates, around $317, with seventy percent of nights sold.
Late summer is the trough. August and September sell just over four nights in ten at rates near $240, in the heart of hurricane season, before October and November start the climb back.
What homes earn in St. Augustine, FL
The chart above follows entire-home rentals inside the City of St. Augustine listed on Airbnb and Vrbo, counting only homes with a guest review score of 4.8 or higher that are available or rented at least 300 days a year — rentals run as a business, not an occasional let. It shows how that standard earns month by month here, from the March and December peaks to the late-summer lull. You can customize a projection for a specific home.
| Month | Total rent | Occupancy | Avg. daily rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jan | $4,453 | 54% | $266 |
| Feb | $4,746 | 67% | $253 |
| Mar | $6,673 | 75% | $287 |
| Apr | $5,134 | 62% | $276 |
| May | $3,984 | 50% | $257 |
| Jun | $4,488 | 55% | $272 |
| Jul | $5,011 | 59% | $274 |
| Aug | $3,089 | 41% | $243 |
| Sep | $3,049 | 42% | $242 |
| Oct | $3,843 | 49% | $253 |
| Nov | $4,822 | 56% | $287 |
| Dec | $6,857 | 70% | $316 |
Get a custom projection for your home
Discover how much your vacation rental could earn with Fairly — No strings attached.
Looking for a home? Find a vacation rental for sale
This is based on properties listed on Airbnb, Vrbo, and Booking.com with an average review score of 4.8 out of 5 or higher, limited to homes available or rented at least 300 days a year. Earnings vary based on the unique amenities and qualities of each home.
A guaranteed $5,000 increase in earnings
We guarantee that homeowners coming from self management or other managers will make an extra $5,000 in their first year with Fairly.
Vacation Rental Taxes and Regulations in St. Augustine, FL
Where your home sits decides the rules
Most homes with a St. Augustine address are outside the city. Crescent Beach, Butler Beach and Vilano Beach are unincorporated St. Johns County; St. Augustine Beach is a separate city; the City of St. Augustine covers the historic downtown, its neighbourhoods and the part of Anastasia Island across the Bridge of Lions.
Lodging taxes
Stays of six months or less owe 11.5%: Florida's 6% sales tax and St. Johns County's 0.5% discretionary sales surtax, both filed with the Florida Department of Revenue, plus the county's 5% tourist development tax, paid to the St. Johns County Tax Collector. The tourist development tax is due monthly, on the first and late after the 20th, with a return filed even in a month without bookings.
Licences every home needs
A Florida DBPR vacation rental licence, once the whole home is rented more than three times a year for under 30 days, and a St. Johns County business tax receipt from the Tax Collector.
Unincorporated St. Johns County
Short-term vacation rentals are allowed in every residential zoning district. East of the Intracoastal Waterway, which takes in all three beach communities, each home is registered with the county and renewed every 12 months. Guests are limited to two per sleeping room or common area, ten in all, not counting children 12 and under, with one off-street parking space per three guests and a fire extinguisher on every floor. Homesteaded homes the owner lives in, and condominiums or other multi-family buildings run by an association or onsite management, are outside the registration.
City of St. Augustine
Nightly rentals are allowed with an annual city registration, renewed by October 1, and a Fire Department life-safety inspection each year. Two exceptions: the single-family neighbourhoods (RS-1, RS-2), on the mainland and across the Bridge of Lions, allow one stay a week; the historic-preservation blocks south of the Plaza de la Constitución (HP-1) allow stays of a month or longer. Check your parcel on the city's zoning map.
City of St. Augustine Beach
Stays under 30 days are barred in low-density residential areas and capped at 100 homes in medium-density ones. Each rental holds a city business tax receipt naming a local contact, and files a rental report by February 1. Your Fairly caretaker can be that contact.
How Fairly handles it
We register your home for the state sales tax and the county tourist development tax, collect and remit both on every booking, and assist with the DBPR licence and the local registration and its renewal.
Operating a vacation rental in St. Augustine, FL
Most Fairly homes here sit on Anastasia Island, a short walk from the dunes, so salt air, blowing sand and summer storms set the maintenance calendar. Turnovers are heaviest through March and again across the holiday-lights season.
The county's rules shape the routine at every turnover. Bins go to the curb no earlier than sunset the evening before collection; the single page posted by the main entrance must show maximum occupancy and vehicles, the evacuation route map, the nearest hospital and the county's marine turtle rules; and guests must leave as soon as a hurricane warning is posted. The rental agreement names a 24-hour contact besides the owner, and your Fairly caretaker, who lives nearby and handles each turnover and walkthrough in person, can be that contact.
Frequently asked questions
A flat 20% commission on rental revenue, paid only when the home books, with no long-term contract and no hidden fees. It covers listings on Airbnb, Vrbo and Fairly.com, pricing, guest messaging, and collecting and remitting the Florida and St. Johns County lodging taxes. Your caretaker earns the cleaning fee guests pay plus a share of Fairly's commission.
In Crescent Beach, Butler Beach, Vilano Beach and the rest of unincorporated St. Johns County, yes, once it is registered with the county. Inside the City of St. Augustine, nightly stays are allowed outside the single-family neighbourhoods (one stay a week there) and the historic blocks south of the Plaza (a month or longer). St. Augustine Beach bars short stays in low-density areas and caps them at 100 homes in medium-density ones.
11.5% on stays of six months or less: Florida's 6% sales tax and St. Johns County's 0.5% surtax, filed with the Department of Revenue, plus the county's 5% tourist development tax, paid monthly to the St. Johns County Tax Collector. Fairly registers your home for both and collects and remits them on every booking.
March and December. March books about three nights in four with spring visitors, and December brings the year's highest nightly rates during the Nights of Lights, which runs from late November into January. August and September are the quietest months, selling just over four nights in ten.

Let’s talk
Fill out some information and we’ll get in touch.
Fairly Vacation Rental Management
Serving St. Augustine, FL and neighboring areas
Available 24/7