The Flamingo House - Sarasota

Home cover photo

Cottage in Sarasota, Florida

4 guests2 bedrooms2 beds2 full baths
5.00
• 1 reviews
Step into a one-of-a-kind Sarasota cottage where historic charm meets modern comfort. Tucked away on a private, fully fenced .36-acre lot shaded by majestic live oaks, swaying palms, and fruit-bearing mango trees, this beautifully updated retreat offers a peaceful escape with a story unlike any other. Originally built as the home of Mr. Martini, an Italian stone carver brought to Sarasota by John Ringling to craft marble fountains and sculptures, this distinctive property is a rare piece of Sarasota history. Thoughtfully updated throughout, the cottage features a bright renovated kitchen with new cabinetry and appliances, stylish new flooring, updated lighting, ceiling fans, a new metal roof, A/C, water heater, and a welcoming new front deck. With two comfortable bedrooms and two baths—one fully renovated and one preserving its vintage charm—this home blends character with convenience. The spacious backyard invites outdoor relaxation, the detached Tiki Hut offers flexibility as a Carport or an outdoor dining area and a place to relax in the shade. Ideally located in one of Sarasota’s vibrant neighborhoods, guests are less than 10 minutes from downtown Sarasota, The Bay Park, Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport, and the dining and cultural attractions along MLK Way. Spend your days exploring the city or relaxing on the white sands of Lido Beach or Siesta Key, before returning to your own private cottage retreat steeped in local history and Old Florida charm. This home is located on a busy street during daylight hours. There is ample room for an RV or boat and trailer within the gated area next to the home. The 1/3 acre lot is surrounded by mature landscaping which creates privacy. Also ample room for family gatherings, picnics and outdoor games.
What this place offers
  • Desk
  • Oven
  • Shower
  • Hair dryer
  • TV
  • Indoor fireplace
  • Heating
  • Dedicated workspace
  • Wifi
  • Baking sheet
Where you'll sleep
Bedroom 1
1 queen
Bedroom 2
1 queen
About the neighborhood
1333 Myrtle Street is located in Sarasota’s Bayou Oaks / North Sarasota area, just north of downtown in an older residential pocket with a mix of historic cottages, bungalows, and newer infill homes. The property itself is in a neighborhood that has been seeing steady revitalization as buyers look for character homes close to downtown at a more accessible price point. Neighborhood highlights: Close to Downtown Sarasota – roughly a 7–10 minute drive to the downtown core, including Main Street Sarasota, restaurants, galleries, and the nearby Bayfront at Indian Shores. Near The Bay waterfront district – convenient to The Bay Park, Sarasota’s large new waterfront park with walking trails, events, and sunset views. Quick airport access – about 10 minutes to Sarasota–Bradenton International Airport, which is useful for second-home owners or vacation rental guests. Beach access – around 15–20 minutes to Lido Beach and St. Armands Circle depending on traffic. Just a bit further you will find Siesta Key with the best rated beaches in the United States. Siesta Village has a vast array of fine restaurants and night life, Local character – the area feels more authentic and less master-planned than many suburban Sarasota neighborhoods, with mature trees, oversized lots in pockets, and eclectic architecture. Also check out the Discovering the Sarasota Succulent Society just a block to the west! Nearby attractions include Jungle Gardens, The Ringling Museum and Ca D'Zan Mansion, Ringling College of Art, the Asolo Repertory Theatre and the Ringling Circus Museum...all must see attractions.
Read more
Getting around
1333 Myrtle Street sits in Sarasota's historic Palm Grove/Gillespie Park area, just north of downtown. The neighborhood has a distinctly urban, evolving character that blends old Florida homes, mature tree canopies, and new redevelopment. The area is known for its eclectic mix of architectural styles, from 1920s cottages and bungalows to contemporary infill homes inspired by Sarasota's modernist design traditions. A defining feature of the neighborhood is its proximity to Gillespie Park, a 10-acre community park with walking trails, sports courts, large oak trees, and green space. Residents enjoy being within minutes of downtown Sarasota's restaurants, arts venues, and waterfront amenities while still living in a neighborhood that retains a residential feel. The area around Myrtle Street is experiencing ongoing revitalization. New residential and mixed-use development in the nearby Rosemary District has brought additional restaurants, cafes, galleries, and businesses within a short bike ride or walk. The neighborhood is increasingly popular among artists, young professionals, and retirees seeking close access to downtown without the higher prices of waterfront districts. Within a few minutes of the property, you'll find local gathering spots such as Blvd Cafe in the Rosemary District, The Breakfast Company downtown, and Hanami Sushi Cocktails, reflecting the growing dining scene in the area. From a practical standpoint, the location offers excellent connectivity. Downtown Sarasota, the bayfront, and The Bay Park are only minutes away, while Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport and the beaches of Lido Key can typically be reached within 10–15 minutes by car. The neighborhood is considered highly bikeable, with some walkability and transit options available. Overall, the area surrounding 1333 Myrtle Street feels authentic and transitional: a historic Sarasota neighborhood with deep roots, abundant mature vegetation, and growing momentum as downtown Sarasota continues to expand northward.
Read more
House rules
  • Check-in after 4:00 PM
  • Check-out before 10:00 AM
  • 4 guests maximum
Safety & property
  • Carbon monoxide alarm installed
  • Fire extinguisher
  • First aid kit
Cancellation policy
Add your trip dates to get the cancellation details for your stay.