Fall and Winter at Lake Shafer

Home cover photoHome photo 1Home photo 2Home photo 3Home photo 4Home photo 5Home photo 6Home photo 7Home photo 8Home photo 9Home photo 10Home photo 11Home photo 12Home photo 13Home photo 14Home photo 15Home photo 16Home photo 17Home photo 18Home photo 19Home photo 20Home photo 21Home photo 22Home photo 23Home photo 24Home photo 25Home photo 26Home photo 27Home photo 28Home photo 29Home photo 30Home photo 31Home photo 32Home photo 33Home photo 34Home photo 35Home photo 36Home photo 37Home photo 38Home photo 39Home photo 40Home photo 41Home photo 42Home photo 43Home photo 44Home photo 45Home photo 46Home photo 47Home photo 48Home photo 49Home photo 50Home photo 51Home photo 52Home photo 53Home photo 54Home photo 55Home photo 56Home photo 57Home photo 58Home photo 59Home photo 60
1 / 61

House in Monticello, Indiana

12 guests • 4 bedrooms • 9 beds • 2 full baths
4.86
• 14 reviews
There’s something extra special about Lake Shafer in the fall. The summer crowds fade, the lake becomes peaceful, the trees begin to show off their reds, golds and oranges, and the cool evenings practically beg for a cozy night at the lake. Come enjoy a slower, more relaxing side of Monticello at our Lake Shafer waterfront home, with beautiful water views, plenty of outdoor space, expansive decks, and your own private shoreline. Spend your days exploring the area, fishing, hiking, shopping, enjoying local events—or simply doing absolutely nothing while watching the lake change with the season. Fall is perfect for: • Scenic drives through the countryside and around the lakes • Fishing and enjoying the peaceful fall water • Exploring local parks and nature trails • Morning coffee overlooking the lake • Family games and outdoor time • Cozy evenings inside with friends and family or outside around the fire pit • Watching the leaves change right from the property Whether you're looking for a fall family getaway, a peaceful couples' weekend, a Thanksgiving gathering, a girls' trip, a holiday escape or simply a place to breathe for a few days, fall and early winter are beautiful times to experience Lake Shafer. And there is plenty happening nearby! Monticello's parks have a full lineup of fall programs. Across the river in Delphi and Carroll County, the Do It In Delphi 5K Run/Walk takes place October 10, and the Delphi area continues to offer community activities and entertainment throughout the fall and winter. The Wabash & Erie Canal Park also hosts fall activities and special events, making Delphi a fun day trip from the lake. And don't forget Halloween! Downtown Monticello's Trunk or Treat is scheduled for Saturday, October 31, from 3–5 PM—a fun option for families visiting over Halloween weekend. Turn your lake getaway into a new holiday tradition! Bring your family to the lake for a memorable Thanksgiving or Christmas holiday. Monticello and Carroll County have activities planned throughout the holiday season, including Monticello's Carols, Cocoa & Cookies celebration, which is scheduled for December 5, followed by the Monticello Lighted Christmas Parade at 6 PM. The sparkling parade travels through downtown Monticello and is a wonderful way to kick off the Christmas season. Over in Delphi, Santa on the Square is scheduled for December 12, bringing even more small-town Christmas charm to the area. And after a day of Christmas shopping, sightseeing or holiday events, there's nothing better than coming back to your own cozy lake house. Come for the events. Stay for the lake. The lake may be quieter in the fall—but that's exactly what makes it special. Bringing your own boat? We'd love to have you enjoy the lake! Please note that boats cannot be left tied to our dock due to lake traffic and changing water conditions. Guests should either rent a slip at a local marina or trailer their boat in and out as needed during their stay. *Please note the wood stove does not work.
What this place offers
  • Microwave
  • Oven
  • Refrigerator
  • Stove
  • Dryer
  • Washing machine
  • Dishwasher
  • Books
  • Arcade games
  • Patio (covered)
Where you'll sleep
Bedroom 1
1 queen
Bedroom 2
1 queen
Sleeping Room
1 full, 2 trundle beds (1 full, 3 twins)
Bedroom 3
1 full
Living Room
1 futon (1 full)
Monticello, IN, USA
About the neighborhood
Nestled along the scenic shores of Lake Shafer in Monticello, this home offers the perfect blend of relaxation and recreation in one of Indiana’s most popular lake destinations. Known for its vibrant boating scene, Lake Shafer attracts visitors looking to enjoy water sports, fishing, and laid-back lakefront living. The surrounding area features a mix of quiet residential pockets and lively attractions, including marinas, waterfront dining, and the nearby Indiana Beach Amusement & Water Park. Nature lovers will also appreciate the proximity to local parks and trails, making it easy to balance adventure with peaceful downtime. Whether you're here for a summer getaway or a weekend escape, the area provides a classic Midwest lake experience with plenty to explore.
Read more
Getting around
Getting around the Lake Shafer and Monticello area is easiest by car, as most attractions, restaurants, and shops are just a short drive away. The property offers convenient access to local roads that connect you to downtown Monticello, marinas, and popular destinations around the lake. Boating is also a major mode of transportation here—many guests enjoy exploring Lake Shafer directly by water, making it easy to visit lakeside restaurants and nearby spots. For those traveling from out of town, the area is accessible via major highways, with Lafayette and other regional hubs within driving distance. Parking is typically ample in the area, making it simple to explore at your own pace.
Read more
House rules
  • Check-in after 4:00 PM
  • Check-out before 10:00 AM
  • 12 guests maximum
Safety & property
  • Exterior security cameras on property
  • Fire extinguisher
  • First aid kit
Cancellation policy
Add your trip dates to get the cancellation details for your stay.

This property is managed through Fairly. It is also available on sites like Airbnb and Vrbo, but the lowest price is always at Fairly.com. Avoid service fees by booking direct.